Wednesday, September 01, 2021

My thoughts on Ivermectin and COVID-19 in early September of 2021

I’ve been following some of the medical research related to COVID-19 and its treatment since the spring of 2020, although my interest in the details of the research is waning. Lately in my news feed I’ve been seeing articles in CNN, Mother Jones, the Washington Post and such sources examining why Americans are taking a “dewormer medication for horses and livestock” (Ivermectin).  Ivermectin has been one of the medications showing some promise as a helpful drug for reducing mortality and symptoms of COVID-19 disease, but what amazes me is how poorly researched these articles are.  All of them make the point that there are “conservative” doctors and “Anti-Vaccination” people promoting the use of Ivermectin. This observation is true, but it disguises the fact that many politically neutral scientists are also suggesting the weight of the evidence supports the idea that Ivermectin is useful. Also, the fact that crazy people (anti-vaccination activists) support a claim tells us nothing about whether the claim is likely to be true.  All the reports make claims that there is “scant evidence” that Ivermectin works, or “flawed studies” suggest it works whereas better studies show it does not. That’s not my understanding of the scientific literature.  I wonder what these journalists were reading to reach such conclusions.  I suspect they were reading accounts by other journalists in an echo-chamber of group-thinking consensus where the assumption is that Ivermectin is wrong.  The Mother Jones article even mentioned Senator Rand Paul suggesting that people were ignoring Ivermectin because they hated Trump.  It’s odd to find myself agreeing with Senator Paul, a politician with whom I generally strongly disagree on almost everything, but I think he might have been right in this case.


The Mother Jones article ties interest in Ivermectin to an April 2020 pre-print of a study based on data provided by Surgisphere, and points out that there was a scandal around a finding concerning hydroxychloroquine studies involved with Surgisphere.  But, the journalist failed to mention that the study in the mentioned scandal was published in The Lancet (not a pre-print, and supposedly peer-reviewed), and gave a finding “debunking” hydroxychloroquine.  If the author of the Mother Jones piece (senior editor Kiera Butler) wanted to illuminate the issue of why people believe Ivermectin might work, she should have explained that at a time when many people thought hydroxychloroquine might be beneficial, a major study was published in a prestigious medical journal showing that the drug was dangerous and ineffective, and days after the publication of the article based on Surgisphere data, authoritative research bodies such as the NIH and WHO seemed to lose interest in studying hydroxychloroqine,  Days later, when The Lancet retracted the article after an outcry by many scientists, journalists did not cover the retraction. This could have undermined people’s faith in prestigious medical journals, authoritative research bodies, and the journalists in the media that gave coverage to a flawed study and ignored the retraction of the study. But, instead of illustrating how the Surgisphere scandal might have supported interest in treatments ignored by mainstream journalism, the Mother Jones article tied belief in Ivermectin as a plausible treatment to Surgisphere’s (garbage) data. And, the Surgisphere data and reports based on it came out in the spring of 2020, whereas continuing research on Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquine has been coming out for over a year afterwards. 



So, the articles that are reporting that there is little reason to believe that Ivermectin is effective are shoddy and misleading. But, what is the evidence for Ivermectin being helpful in some cases of COVID-19? There is a research review of over 50 studies at https://c19ivermectin.com. A look over the research accumulated and reviewed there suggests that the evidence for Ivermectin being at least somewhat effective in early treatment is hardly “scant” and looks more like it’s “overwhelming” to me. What we need is a serious journalist to look over this evidence and explain why it is flawed or biased, or else explain how it is not flawed and biased, and likely to be correct.  Now, the closest thing we have to this (that I am aware of) is the Cochrane Library entry on Ivermectin by Maria Popp and colleagues. And particularly, if you read the discussion by Popp et al. at the end of their Cochrane review (under the heading "Agreements and disagreements with other studies or reviews"). It explains that positive ivermectin results in other people's studies are because the researchers included studies with greater limitations (e.g., using ivermectin and doxycycline together instead of just using ivermectin, or including a sample in which some persons did not have positive COVID tests, etc.).  


Since the overwhelming proportion of studies investigating Ivermectin that are cited by the Frontline Critical Care Alliance and the Ivermectin website have been positive, I wanted to look at the studies showing it is not effective.  The Brazilian study headed by Luis Enrique Bermejo Galan (https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/20477724.2021.1890887?needAccess=true&) for example, compared Ivermectin, chloroquine, and hydroxychloroquine in treating patients in a Brazilian hospital in Roraima. The team found mortality rates of 21.3% to 23.0% for patients, without any significant difference depending upon which drug they received. However, there was no control group of similarly severely afflicted patients to compare to the three groups that received medications, and the authors suggest that mortality rates of 21-23% are standard for other studies where patients receive placebos, which is why they interpret their results as showing the medications were ineffective. But the pro-Ivermectin research review site https://c19ivermectin.com reviews this paper and points out that Northern Brazil (where Roraima is located) had mortality rates of 43% for persons with COVID-19 who were admitted to hospitals, and if there had been a randomized fourth group of patients who received none of the three medications with a mortality rate of 43%, that would have indicated that the three examined drugs were effective in lowering morality. 


I’m open-minded about Ivermectin, and I think that the evidence (flawed though it is) showing Ivermectin works is persuasive.  The handful of studies showing it does not effectively improve survival or diminish symptoms in COVID-19 cases are also flawed, and do not convincingly show it is ineffective. If Ivermectin is effective, and I think it probably is, it seems to work best as a prophylaxis or in early treatment, and it seems about half as effective used in cases where symptoms are severe and patients are being admitted to hospitals. It’s quite plausible to me that some things like Zinc and Vitamin D and so forth could be mildly beneficial if levels are high before infection or if someone takes doses immediately after infection, but the same substances might be entirely ineffective if taken after symptoms have become severe. This is a possibility that many journalists writing about such interventions seem to miss or dismiss. But, diseases often go through different stages, and interventions that are appropriate at one stage of a disease may be inappropriate at other stages. There is nothing unusual about that. But studies that only test the effectiveness of interventions that are administrated in later stages, after they would be effective, will be misinterpreted to "prove" that the interventions are "ineffective" when in fact they may be effective if provided at a an earlier (or later) stage, or in combination with some other substance.


Critiques of those who hold faith in Ivermectin I’ve read do get one thing right. People who don’t like vaccinations and others who do accept vaccinations are sometimes exaggerating the supposed (and probable) benefits of Ivermectin. One friend suggested to me that Ivermectin and vitamins were more effective than vaccines. Even persons who are frequently accurate and competent in their analysis of COVID-19 (such as Chris Martenson of Peak Prosperity), are sometimes getting caught up in this idea that the research we have on Ivermectin suggests it’s more effective than, for example, the Pfizer or Moderna vaccines. 


Let me point out a few things.  First of all, America has been vaccinating adults since late December with vaccines, now three of them, including Pfizer (I had Pfizer shots in April).  A bit more than half of American adults are fully vaccinated.  If the vaccines were entirely ineffective, current hospitalization rates and death rates would be about equal between vaccinated adults and non-vaccinated adults.  Maybe a little over half of adults are vaccinated, so a little over half of those in hospitals and morgues from COVID-19 would be vaccinated.  Instead, about 95% or more of those who are dying or hospitalized are unvaccinated. Some reports suggests that it’s 99% of the hospitalized and dying who are unvaccinated.  That suggests to me that the vaccines are significantly reducing risks of death or hospitalization. It turns out that those of us who are fully vaccinated are also more likely to be continuing our social distancing, mask-wearing, and better hygiene, so that complicates the picture, but still, it seems about 90% to 98% fewer vaccinated adults are in hospital or morgues due to COVID-19.  The studies of Ivermectin suggest it reduces risks of death or hospitalization by something between 40% and 80%, and if there is an effect (there almost certainly is), it’s probably something like a 60% to 70% protection. That’s not as good as the vaccines.  


The vaccines we are using in the USA are proven to reduce chances of getting sick from COVID-19, going to the hospital because of the severity of COVID-19, and dying from COVID-19.  The demographics of those now in hospitals or cemeteries from COVID-19 in the past few months compared to the demographics of who has been vaccinated suggest the vaccines are over 90% effective. Studies of Ivermectin, even the most promising studies, do not suggest it is that effective. Both the vaccines and ivermectin are relatively safe.  Ivermectin probably is “safer” than the vaccines, but neither Ivermectin nor the vaccines are likely to cause serious harm or death, if appropriate doses are taken. Getting an overdose of ivermectin can be serious, however. The high death rates we are now experiencing are from unvaccinated persons who are dying from COVID-19 or other persons who can’t get medical care for other problems because unvaccinated persons with COVID-19 are clogging up our hospitals.  We are not seeing many deaths due to bad reactions to vaccination (or overdosing on Ivermectin, for that matter).  Ivermectin use (and belief that the scientific evidence supports the proposition that Ivermectin is likely to be beneficial in preventing bad cases of COVID-19) is compatible with use of vaccines (and belief that vaccine use dramatically helps prevent bad COVID-19 cases).  


Some people are claiming that natural immunity and ivermectin plus vitamins is safer and better than vaccination.  If one is vaccinated, there is a slight chance of death or a serious reaction that causes long-term harm, and I don’t know what that risk is precisely, but I believe it’s something like 1-in-800,000 or 1-in-a-million.  The odds of getting a “serious” reaction with fever and feeling sick for an afternoon, or a day, or a few days is much higher, but death and  permanent serious harm is, as far as I can figure, very rare. Without a vaccine if one gets COVID-19 one’s risk of death varies by one’s age and underlying health, but even robust young persons have died from COVID-19, and risk of death seems to be something like 1-in-300 for young and healthy to 1-in-50 for elderly persons in poor health.  So, even if natural immunity from getting COVID is “better” than vaccination, the risks you take by seeking a natural immunity are far, far more threatening than the risks of getting a vaccine. There are many “breakthrough” cases where fully vaccinated persons get COVID-19, but it seems most of the positive test results for fully vaccinated persons who get COVID-19 are associated with no symptoms of illness or very mild symptoms such as a runny nose. Very few get seriously ill, and almost none die.  Those fully vaccinated persons who do get seriously ill or die seem to almost entirely have multiple risk factors, and the most serious risk factor is a compromised immune system.  Persons with compromised immune systems seem to be at high risk from getting bad or lethal cases of COVID even if they get vaccinated. It’s true that a large percent (perhaps a third) of non-vaccinated persons who get COVID also show no symptoms, and most have only mild flu-like symptoms, but a large minority of those who get COVID get very sick, or are sick for a very long time, or have long-term impairments even if they had no serious illness. Maybe a third of unvaccinated persons who get COVID-19 have serious illness or long-term problems, and maybe 0.5% to 2% die.  The facts suggests that almost everyone is better off getting their natural immunity from direct exposure to the actual SARS-CoV-2 after they have been vaccinated.  


I think governments and health authorities are promoting vaccine use because the evidence shows us that vaccines are extremely effective and relatively safe (but not perfectly safe).  I think governments and health authorities in many countries are resisting the use of Ivermectin because, although there is good evidence for Ivermectin’s value, that evidence is associated with deviant ideas or critical ideas that question the accuracy of government health authorities and leading research bodies.  Those who lead medical establishment institutions in governments or health authorities and research bodies do not like criticisms of them, especially unfair and conspiracy-mongering criticisms, and since they associate Ivermectin research and support with those ideas, they have a bias against Ivermectin. That is my understanding the most likely explanation for why there is not a more positive and open-minded attitude toward Ivermectin.  


Humans are not really good at running conspiracies. The larger the conspiracy, the easier it is for people to betray the conspiracy.  But, humans are very good at suffering from cognitive distortions, confirmation bias, and tribal us-versus-them thinking.  I think many mainstream scientists and journalists are blinded about ivermectin because of their biases and their group thinking and conformity.  A similar situation goes on with many who remain uncertain about vaccinations.  Those who doubt the efficacy of vaccinations and trust in ivermectin or hydroxychloroquine or Vitamin D or Zinc will tend to notice all the good evidence for those things, and ignore any evidence that those don’t work as well as they hope.  They will be hyper-alert in perceiving how mainstream journalists and scientists are ignoring the positive evidence for the efficacy of those approaches.  They will note all the real issues with vaccines, the real problems with how profits go to large pharmaceutical companies, and the real cases of governments using stupid policies to control COVID-19, but they will give disproportionate mental energy to thinking about such things, and not get an objective perspective.  Yes, the vaccines aren’t as good as they were supposed to be, and there are some people having bad reactions to them, but those facts are essentially trivial noise around the very significant fact that vaccines are mostly safe and very good at preventing hospitalization and death from COVID-19. Yes, big pharmaceutical companies are raking in money, and many leading researchers have been “captured” by the mentality and approaches that allow big pharmaceutical companies to set up the health care system in ways that make their owners rich and supply many doctors with medications of dubious value.  That, however, is a tangent that has no bearing on the fact that the vaccines are working pretty well to prevent hospitalization and death from COVID-19.


******

Update a couple years later.  The evidence for the efficacy of ivermectin against COVID-19 has not entirely melted away, but it has diminished. The evidence of dishonesty and unethical behavior by some of the leadership in the American public health bureaucracy has confirmed that there were attempts to deceive the public on a few matters (for example, the claim that "all the experts agree it is impossible that the virus came from a lab" was false and the people who made that claim knew it was false when they made it). Within two years of the release of the COVID vaccines I'll have had five shots, I continue to wear masks when I'm in crowded indoor places for any significant length of time, and I have so far never knowingly had COVID-19.  


Wednesday, March 10, 2021

What to include in an introduction to (history of) alternative and indie music?

 I'm very fond of music, and I have eclectic tastes.  I decorate time with music when it doesn't distract me from other duties, often using classical or ambient music while working, and sometimes using popular music while doing other activities. I was actually a DJ on a small local nonprofit radio station when I was a teenager.

The music that tends to be most popular usually holds no attraction for me, and most of my favorite popular music is from alternative or independent label musicians. I'm interested in creating a series of podcasts or radio programs in Mandarin Chinese to introduce such music to an audience in Taiwan (and China, perhaps).  One of my motives is to help create a market demand for live concerts by the sort of bands that in America would play in venues with audiences of several hundred up to a thousand.  The big name bands that can play in huge venues are already known all over the world, and the unknown bands that tour on a shoestring and play to audiences of fewer than a couple hundred can also make a go of it, but the middle-tier popularity bands have a hard time touring in East Asia because they are too famous to tolerate the low returns they would get performing in small venues, but not famous enough to have much of an audience outside of North America, Europe, and Australia/New Zealand/Japan.  

So, what would I include on such a series of podcasts, and what would I say about the songs?  For an hour of programming, you need about 48-52 minutes of music, leaving you with 4-6 minutes for explanation/description and another few minutes of station identification, weather, or advertising and public service announcements.

Hour 1: The antecedents.

Garage Band sound:

Louie Louie (Kingsman) 1963 (out of Portland, Oregon—my father went to high school with these guys)

Surfin’ Bird (Trashman) 1963 (out of Minneapolis, Minnesota)

Sometimes garage bands could break big, as the Kingsman and Trashmen did in 1963. This was "outsider" music at its time, but it had broad appeal.

Independent label

Apache (The Ventures) 1962 (out of Tacoma, Washington, recording on the independent label Dolton out of Seattle, Washington)

Pipeline (Dick Dale) 1963 (from Massachusetts and Southern California, started out on his own label, Deltone Records)

Dick Dale and The Ventures were extremely influential on rock music. 

British Invasion

You really Got Me (The Kinks) 1964 (London, England).  Important because it was loud and super simple.  Loud and simple, with a garage band sound, this provides a foundation for the alternative music that was to come later, such as punk music.

Psychedelia and Glam Rock

A Dream for Julie (Kaleidoscope) 1967 (London, England), a representative sample of the sort of music called psychedelia, which was extremely popular from 1967-1969, and is associated with popular bands such as The Beatles, Jefferson Airplane, The Jimi Hendrix Experience, and the Moody Blues.  This music took a philosophical position, and questioned many assumptions of mainstream culture and music, and thus influenced other artists to write music that challenged the values and assumptions of mainstream world-views.

All Tomorrow's Parties (The Velvet Underground) 1967 (New York City). The Velvet Underground were an influential part of the countercultural music scene, and an important inspiration for many alternative bands that followed. The band was not only musically influential, as the popular uprising to change the Communist government in the Czechoslovakian Republic was called the “Velvet Revolution” partly because many of the activists were very fond of the Velvet Underground.  Lou Reed and John Cale, two members of this band, continued to be extremely important in creating innovated sounds and musical forms for decades following.

Ride a White Swan (T. Rex, Marc Bolan) 1970 (London, England), Glam Rock such as the early music of David Bowie and the work of Marc Bolan was extremely popular, and included performances and costuming that questioned presentation of gender. The music and performances were sometimes shocking and outrageous, a characteristic that was also an important ingredient of some early alternative music.

Experimental and Electronica

St. Elmo's Fire  (Brian Eno) 1975 (London, England), Brian Eno was a significant innovator in electronic and guitar music and sounds. He is one of the founders of the ambient music form. He also created innovative popular music that influenced others who were interested in sounds that were different from the mainstream. 

Franz Schubert - Endless Endless  (Kraftwerk) 1977, Synthesizers and electronic music were another part of the alternative approach to music, and Krafwerk basically introduced this sound and approach, which became so influential in the 1980s.

Regiment (Brian Eno & David Byrne) 1981 (New York City). This album was influential for its use of sampled music, and this song uses the voice of Dunya Yunis, a Lebanese mountain singer, whose performance Eno and Byrne found on a world music collection Music in the World of Islam. The mixing of sounds on this album inspired many later artists, and such unusual and experimental music was generally only heard on stations or programming that included alternative and indie, punk and new wave.

American innovators of the 1970s

Roadrunner (Jonathan Richman & The Modern Lovers) 1972 (Boston, MA). Jonathan Richman was an example of an eccentric outsider whose music was inspiring to other artists who wanted to do something different. 

No More Mr. Nice Guy (Alice Cooper) 1973 (Phoenix, AZ, with roots in Detroit, Michigan). Alice Cooper was a mainstream popular band, but like the glam rock of England, the band used unusual costuming and stage performances that were described as “Shock Rock”. Their songs and performances were critical of mainstream values and institutions.

Marquee Moon (Television) 1977 (New York City). Television were important influence on punk and alternative music, especially with their emphasis on basic guitar sounds. 

Hour 2: Early Indie and Punk in the USA

Loud, Dirty, Rock

Two important groups who brought the earlier forms of popular music toward the underground and alternative side are the Stooges and the New York Dolls. In particular, Iggy Pop, the leader of the Stooges, is sometimes credited with starting the punk music scene in the United States. Sometimes the New York Dolls are credited with this. At any rate, we will hear an early Stooges song from 1969, a mid-70s song from Iggy Pop as a solo artist without the Stooges, and an example of what the New York Dolls sounded like around 1973. These artists are known for a raw, loud sound, and their powerful influence on subsequent bands that shaped American punk and rock-n-roll in the late 1970s through the 1980s.

I Wanna Be Your Dog (The Stooges) 1969 (Detroit, Michigan), 

The Passenger (Iggy Pop) 1977 (Detroit, Michigan), 

Personality Crisis (New York Dolls) 1973 (New York City), 

  The influence of the CBGB music venue in New York City.

The CBGB music club in Manhattan, New York City (1973-2006) was originally intended as a venue for country, bluegrass, and blues music. However, in the mid-late 1970s it was the place where many of the punk and new wave bands played.  In the 1980s it became more known as a venue for the eighties style punk music and hardcore punk, a form of punk that was very angry, fast, and masculine. This is where bands like the Ramones, Blondie, The Talking Heads, the Cramps, and the Fleshtones performed. The Damned, one of the first punk bands out of the British punk movement first played in America at CBGB.  The genre of punk when it first appeared in America was not always as angry, fast, and loud as it became later in the 1980s. The following songs give a sense of the diversity of the New York punk sound in the mid-to-late 1970s:

Blitzkrieg Bop (The Ramones) 1976  (New York City), 

Heart of Glass (Blondie) 1978  (New York City), 

Mind (Talking Heads) 1979  (New York City), 

Animals (Talking Heads) 1979  (New York City), 

Those last two songs are from the Talking Heads, another extremely influential band. The next two songs are by the Cramps, a band that, like the Ramones who opened the previous set, played a simple style of music that was trying to get at the attractive basics of rock-n-role as it existed in the 1950s or early 1960s. In fact, the second Cramps song I’ll play (Green Door) is a cover of a 1956 song. The Cramps are notable also for being one of the first bands to sign with the I.R.S. record label. The punk and alternative and indie forms of popular music initially represented bands creating their own labels, rather than working with the major music industry companies, and I.R.S. was one of the early record labels set up to record, produce, and market this music. I.R.S. is what would be known as an independent label, like the Dolton label the Ventures had used for their music, or the Deltone label Dick Dale created for his music. 

The Mad Daddy (the Cramps) 1979 (New York City). Illegal Records label was a precursor of I.R.S. label (Stewart Copeland involved with both). 

The Green Door (the Cramps) 1981 (New York City).  An early record on the I.R.S. label.

Blue Mask (Lou Reed) 1981  (New York City), 

That last song, Blue Mask, was the title cut from an album Lou Reed released with the major label RCA in 1981. Lou Reed had been part of the Velvet Underground, and this song represents the fact that by the early 1980s, major record labels were signing artists from the underground, new wave, and punk scenes, and some of the earlier founders of alternative popular music were, while not becoming mainstream, at least gaining a wider audience.

Punk, West Coast and Washington, DC

The punk genre was one of the main streams of counter-cultural popular music that evolved into alternative rock. It was thriving all around the country by the end of the 1970s and early 1980s. Here is a song by the extremely influential San Francisco band Dead Kennedys, whose overtly political songs inspired fans all over the world who enjoyed radical or anarchist politics with their anarchic loud punk music. On the other side of the continent, in Washington, DC the independent record label Dischord, which is still in business, was a leading source for the louder and noisier forms of punk that became hardcore, and, in the case of this song by the Rites of Spring, you can hear one of the earliest examples of the form of music that became “emo”, named for its extremely raw emotional lyrics and singing style. 

Holiday in Cambodia (the Dead Kennedys) 1980 (San Francisco), a “political punk” band

Hidden Wheel (Rites of Spring) 1985  (Washington, DC), probably deserves to be called the first “emo” band.

Just as punk was becoming louder, faster, and more male-dominated, other punk artists or those attracted to punk started becoming more proficient at playing their instruments, started playing with more pop sensibilities and more accessible melodies, and as a result, began to gain a wider audience.  The phenomenon of music videos and an early cable network station that played music videos all the time (MTV) also exposed Americans who lived far from the cultural centers where more innovative artists were developing new sounds, to music unlike what they could hear on the their local radio stations.  For American young people living in rural areas or small cities, unless they had a college station they could listen to with their radios, just about the only way they could hear music like this was on the MTV network, which occasionally put videos by new wave or alternative artists into their play rotation, and eventually established a special program to feature such music for a couple hours each week. 

Wall of Voodoo and the Go-Gos are two Los Angeles representatives of this Post-Punk or “New Wave” sound that was capable of attracting a mass audience. R.E.M., out of the college town of Athens, Georgia, also played a form of accessible music that owed more to folk music than to the angry, loud punk music that was popular, but this form was so unlike the type of music that then dominated the radios, that it all was grouped together as alternative music. While these bands started out obscure and unknown, and the Go-Gos were certainly in the “punk” genre when they started out, some of this music caught the public’s attention and generated hits for the artists.  The Go-Gos were near the top of the popular music charts in 1982 with Vacation, and R.E.M. eventually became huge, playing to stadiums.  Other massively popular bands such as U2 started out this way, initially touring North America playing in small college campus venues, and ending up among the elite super-famous musical leaders in culture.

Diversity in Post-Punk and New Wave and Alternative music in the early 1980s

Animal Day (Wall of Voodoo) 1980 (Los Angeles), Post-punk New Wave

Vacation (the Go Gos) 1982 (Los Angeles), American New Wave music

Radio Free Europe (R.E.M.) 1983  (Athens, Georgia), Post-punk alternative music (folk influences)


Hour 3: The take off of independent and punk music in the UK.

In the United Kingdom, as in the United States, many musicians and aspiring musicians were deeply dissatisfied with the forms of rock-and-roll that were popular on the radio. The dominance of easy listening, progressive rock, disco, and vapid popular music irritated these persons, and as did the control of the major recording labels over what was marketed to the public.

Throughout the United Kingdom, some of these artists formed garage bands, or they started building their own electronic instruments, or they innovated with new forms of sound and approaches to music.  At the same time, many people who liked this approach, and wanted to escape the dominance of the major record labels, or else had no chance of catching the attention of record company executives, started creating their own recording studios and record labels.  Punk music was an important part of this trend, but a wide variety of artists adopted the do-it-yourself attitude and countercultural rejection of mainstream music while creating music that sounded nothing like the punk music of such famous bands as The Sex Pistols or The Clash.  

This first song is by the Clash, one of these bands that was vocal in its criticism of major record labels. The song Complete Control complains about the way record labels mistreated the musical artists who signed contracts with the music industry giants. After Complete Control by the Clash, we’ll hear Boredom by the Buzzcocks, a band that was the first one to establish their own independent label (the New Hormones label) to pay for the pressing and distribution of their Spiral Scratch extended play record. The song was recorded in a short (three hour) session, and mixed in about two hours, and then master tapes were taken to be pressed into vinyl. So, let us now hear a song by a major label punk band complaining about artists being mistreated, and a song by punk artists who were doing it all on their own without the help of a big record label company. 

Complete Control (The Clash) 1977 (London, England), Punk song criticizing the behavior of CBS Records.  

Boredom (the Buzzcocks) 1977 (Manchester, England),  one of the first UK punk albums, and the first one a band made on their own label. 

X-Ray Spex were one of the early punk bands, the led singer was a woman, who went by the name Poly Styrene. She is one of the first in a line of women who have enjoyed the loud and angry sounds of punk and alternative music.  The saxophonist was a 16-year old girl named Susan Whitby. This song is an attack on consumerism, which is described as bondage, as if persons deluded by capitalism and the pursuit of consumer goods are engaged in a masochistic fetish. After this song from 1977, we hear a 1979 song by the post-punk band Gang of Four, expressing similar sentiments about the failures of capitalism and consumerism.

Oh Bondage (Up Yours) (X-Ray Spex) 1977 (London, England)

Natural’s Not In It (Gang of Four) 1979 (Leeds, England)

Convincing People (Throbbing Gristle) 1979 (Kingston upon Hull, England)

We are continuing now with some of this innovative music that was coming out on small, independent labels in the late 1970s and early 1980s. 

Interzone (Joy Division) 1979 (Salford, England)

Temptation 
(New Order) 1979 (Manchester, England)

Electricity (Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark) 1980 (Liverpool area, England). Dindisc Records

Read It In Books (Echo and the Bunnymen) 1979 (Liverpool, England). Zoo Records

Honey Mad Woman (The Raincoats) 1983 (London, England). Rough Trade label.

Felicity (Orange Juice) 1982 (Glasgow, Scotland). Postcard Records.

I Melt With You (Modern English) 1982 (Colchester, England). 4AD Records (Beggars Banquet)

Ghost Town (The Specials) 1981 (Coventry, England). 2 Tone Records
 
Ranking Full Stop (The English Beat) 1979 (Birmingham, England. 2 Tone Records / Go Feet Records (Go Feet was a label created by the Beat to produce and sell their records).

New Life (Depeche Mode) 1981 (London's far eastern suburbs, England) Mute Records.  British Synthpop initially also came out of independent labels.  

Hour 4: More Post-Punk and Do-It-Yourself music out of the UK

I Don't Know What To Do With My Life (The Buzzcocks) 1979

Love Will Tear Us Apart (Joy Division) 1979

Bunker Soldiers (Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark) 1980

Second Skin (The Chameleons) 1983

Eighties (Killing Joke) 1984

Blue Monday (New Order) 1983

(This Is Not A) Love Song (Public Image Limited) 1983

No Bulbs 3 (The Fall) 1984

Rusholme Ruffians (The Smiths) 1984

The Cutter (Echo & The Bunnymen) 1985

Ocean Rain (Echo & The Bunnymen) 1984

I Promise (Radiohead) 1997

Hour 5: College Radio Music

Genius of Love (Tom Tom Club) 1981

These Dangerous Machines (Martha and the Muffins) 1983

Seven Chinese Brothers (R.E.M.) 1984

Alex Chilton (The Replacements) 1987

Take the Skinheads Bowling (Camper Van Beethoven) 1985

Don't Let's Start (They Might Be Giants) 1985

When Men Were Trains (Big Dipper) 1987

Boy (Book of Love) 1986

Years Later (Cactus World News) 1986

Why Are You Being so Reasonable Now? (The Wedding Present) 1987

I Love Hot Nights (Jonathan Richman) 1987

Here Comes Your Man (Pixies) 1990

So You Think You're In Love (Robyn Hitchcock & the Egyptians) 1991

Not Too Soon (Throwing Muses) 1991

Hour 6:  Punk, Pop-Punk, Riot Grrrl

Punk wasn’t necessarily “hardcore” yet

Where Next Columbus? (Crass) 1981

Run Like A Villain (Iggy Pop) 1982

Southern California

TV Party (Black Flag) 1981

The Hammer Hits The Nail (The Flesh Eaters) 1983

The Cheerleaders (Minutemen) 1985

Washington DC, Dischord Records, Ian MacKaye

Minor Threat (Minor Threat) 1984

Waiting Room (Fugazi) 1989

Twin Cities and Midwest

Love Is the Law (The Suburbs) 1982

Guns at My School (Hüsker Dü) 1981

Chartered Trips (Hüsker Dü) 1984

I Can't Hardly Wait  (The Replacements) 1985

Heartbeat (Big Black) 1987

The 90s.  Emo and Riot Grrrl

In Circles (Sunny Day Real Estate) 1994

Rebel Girl (Bikini Kill) 1993

Get Up (Sleater-Kinney) 1999


Hour 7:  Grunge, 1990s, Pacific Northwest

Early influences (from Massachusetts!) KAOS-fm radio and Calvin Johnson 

Out There (Dinosaur Jr.) 1993

Feel the Pain (Dinosaur Jr.) 1994

Good Enough (Mudhoney) 1991

Cry for a Shadow (Beat Happening) 1991

Seattle

Smells Like Teen Spirit (Nirvana) 1991

All Apologies (Nirvana) 1993

Spoonman (Soundgarden) 1994

Better Man (Pearl Jam) 1994

California

Interstate Love Song (Stone Temple Pilots) 1994

Doll Parts (Hole) 1994

Idaho

Big Dipper (Built to Spill) 1994

Untrustable / Part 2 (Built to Spill) 1997



Hour 8:  1990s Alternative

UK early 1990s popular on College Radio in the USA

Tonight I Fancy Myself (The Beautiful South) 1990.  From Hull, England

Right Here, Right Now (Jesus Jones) 1990. From Wiltshire, England

Grey Cell Green (Ned's Atomic Dustbin) 1991. From Stourbridge, near Birmingham, England

Yr Own World (Blue Airplanes) 1991. From Bristol, England

Early 90s American Sounds that weren't grunge

And Hiding Away (The Innocence Mission) 1991.  From Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Fortune Cookie Prize (Beat Happening) 1992. From Olympia, Washington

Line Song (Shrimp Boat) 1993. From Chicago, Illinois

Feeling Down in the mid-90s?

Loser (Beck) 1993. From Southern California
Self-Esteem (The Offspring) 1994. From Southern California
All the Umbrellas in London (The Magnetic Fields) 1995.  From Boston, Massachusetts 
Snare, Girl (Sonic Youth) 1998. New York City 

Late 1990s

Date with Ikea (Pavement) 1997. From New York City 
Randy Described Eternity (Built to Spill) 1997 (but play the version from Live, 2000). From Boise, Idaho

Hour 9:  Accessible (Beautiful) Alternative Music

The 1980s

Avalon (Roxy Music) 1982. From London, England

Down on Mission Street (Lloyd Cole and the Commotions) 1984.  From Glasgow, Scotland

Among the Americans (10,000 Maniacs) 1985. From Jamestown, New York

Up On The Sun (The Meat Puppets) 1985. From Phoenix, Arizona

You (Tuxedomoon) 1987. From San Francisco, California

Birthday (The Sugar Cubes) 1988. From Reykjavik, Iceland

You Keep It All In (The Beautiful South) 1989. From Hull, England

The 1990s

The Guitar (The Lion Sleeps Tonight) (They Might Be Giants) 1992.  From New York City

Angels with Dirty Faces (Los Lobos) 1993. From Los Angeles, California

Mustard (Latin Playboys) 1999.  From Los Angeles, California

Sylvia (Creeper Lagoon) 1997. From San Francisco, California

Is It Wicked Not To Care? (Belle & Sebastian) 1998. From Glasgow, Scotland

Virginia Reel Around the Fountain (The Halo Benders) 1998. From Boise, Idaho and Olympia, Washington.


Hour 10: The New Millennium 

1999 

Millennium Cars (Keith Secola) 1999. Ojibwa singer from Cook, Minnesota

Waitin' for a Superman (Is it Getting Heavy?) (the Flaming Lips) 1999. From Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Carry the Zero (Built to Spill) 1999. From Boise, Idaho

Else (Built to Spill) 1999. From Boise, Idaho

2000 

Balls (Sparks) 2000. From Southern California 

Legal Man (Belle & Sebastian) 2000. From Glasgow, Scotland

The New You (Tim Keegan & Departure Lounge) 2000. From London, England

The Littlest Birds (The Be Good Tanyas) 2000. From Vancouver, British Columbia

The Sailor in Love with the Sea (The 6ths) 2000. From Massachusetts (Stephin Merritt)

Bohemian Like You (The Dandy Warhols) 2000. From Portland, Oregon

Later On

Elephant Song (Sky Cries Mary) 2003. From Seattle, Washington

Museum of Idiots (They Might Be Giants) 2004. From New York City

One Chance (Modest Mouse) 2004. From Seattle and Portland


Hour 11: Below the Equator

New Zealand (and Flying Nun Records)

Six Months in a Leaky Boat (Split Enz) 1982.

Loving Grapevine (Jean-Paul Sartre Experience) 1986.

The Crying Room (David Mitchell and Denise Roughen) 1996.

The Record Store (The Brunettes) 2004.

The Sun (The Naked and Famous) 2010.

Australia

Don't Change (INXS) 1983. 

Right Here (The Go-Betweens) 1987.

Beds Are Burning (Midnight Oil) 1987.

I'm a Believer (Anita Lane) 1993.

Beautiful Trash (Lanu) 2007.  ( Lance Ferguson is originally from New Zealand)

Morning Song (The Babe Rainbow) 2019.

South Africa

Bafana Bafana (Cop On the Edge) 2010. 

Fire Is Low (Freshlyground) 2010. 

Down South (Jeremy Loops) 2015.


Hour 12: Europe in the 80s 

Electronic, Industrial, and Experimental

Cars (Gary Numan) 1979. From London, England

Collapsing New People (Fad Gadget) 1985.  From London, England

Yü-Gung (Einstürzende Neubauten) 1985.  From Berlin, Germany

Headhunter (Front 242) 1988. From Belgium

Sympathy for the Devil (Dem Teufel Zugeneigt) (Laibach) 1989. From Slovenia

More Mainstream and Popular

Up On The Catwalk (Simple Minds) 1984. From Glasgow, Scotland

Marcia Baila (Les Rita Mitsouko) 1985. From Paris, France

Ask (The Smiths) 1986. From Manchester, England

Just Like Heaven (The Cure) 1987.  From Crawley, West Sussex, England

Björk in the 1990s

Human Behavior (Björk) 1993. From Reykjavik, Iceland

Covering 1980s Alternative Songs decades later

Fade to Grey (Nouvelle Vague) 2006. From Paris, France


Hour 13: New York City

Introduction to the New York City scene

Chinatown (Luna) 1995. 

The 2000s

You Only Live Once (The Strokes) 2005. 

Forever Song (Mosquitos) 2003.  

Don't Tell Them (Paul Brill) 2006. 

Someone Great (LCD Soundsystem) 2007.

Two Weeks (Grizzly Bear) 2009.

Laughing With (Regina Spektor) 2009.

Knotty Pine (Dirty Projectors & David Byrne) 2009.

The 2010s

Tragically Alright (Ex-Cops featuring Ariel Pink) 2014. 

Give Me Just A Minute (Computer Magic) 2015.  

Crying in the Sunshine (Miniature Tigers) 2017. 

Seventeen (Sharon Van Etten) 2019.

We are in the 20s now

Overlord (Dirty Projectors) 2020. 

Everything is Gonna Be All Right (Infinity Song) 2020.


Hour 14: East Coast 

Vampire Weekend and Rostam (New York City, but Rostam lives in Los Angeles now)

A-Punk (Vampire Weekend) 2008. 

Bike Dream (Rostam) 2017. 

Rich Man (Vampire Weekend) 2019

New England

Gigantic (Pixies) 1988. From Boston, Massachusetts

Art Isn't Real (City of Sin) (Deer Tick) 2007.  From Providence, Rhode Island

Sleepyhead (Passion Pit) 2008.  From Cambridge, Massachusetts

Just One Look (The Derevolutions) 2018. From Boston, Massachusetts

Have Some Fun

Considering A Move To Memphis (The Colorblind James Experience) 1987. From Rochester, New York

Every Hour Here (Innocence Mission) 1991. From Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Ohm (Yo La Tengo) 2013. From Hoboken, New Jersey

Mid-Atlantic

Arpeggiator (Fugazi) 1998. From Washington, DC

Shade And Honey (Sparklehorse) 2006.  From Richmond, Virginia

Easy (Thao with The Get Down Stay Down) 2009.  From Falls Church, Virginia (now relocated to San Francisco)


Hour 15: Canada

The 2000s, Anglophone Canada

Anthems For a Seventeen Year Old Girl (Broken Social Scene) 2003. Toronto, Ontario

Precious Metals (Russian Futurists) 2003. Toronto, Ontario

Haiti (Arcade Fire) 2004. Montreal, Quebec

Sing Me Spanish Techno (The New Pornographers) 2005. Vancouver, British Columbia

Jamelia (Caribou) 2010. Hamilton, Ontario

What about Francophone Canada? (it is more “pop” than alternative)

Montréal (Ariane Moffatt) 2005. Montreal, Quebec

Tourne encore (Salomé Leclerc) 2011. Sainte-Françoise, Quebec

Rêves d'été (Laurence Nerbonne) 2015. Gatineau, Quebec

The 10's in Anglophone Canada

The Lamb (Little Scream) 2011. Montreal, Quebec

Da Dunda (Slam Dunk) 2012. Victoria, British Columbia

Amerika (Wintersleep) 2016. Halifax, Nova Scotia

Utopia (Austra) 2017. Toronto, Ontario

Saved by a Waif (Alvvays) 2017. Toronto, Ontario (but from Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island)

Texas (Jennifer Castle) 2018. Toronto, Ontario


Hour 16: The American South

Rockabilly and Psychobilly

Bales of Cocaine (Reverend Horton Heat) 1993. From Dallas, Texas

Deja Varoom (Southern Culture on the Skids) 1997. From Chapel Hill, North Carolina

College Towns

A Thousand Years (Azure Ray) 2002. From Athens, Georgia

Id Engager (Of Montreal) 2008. From Athens, Georgia

Ain’t No Rest for the Wicked (Cage the Elephant) 2009. From Bowling Green, Kentucky (but they have relocated to London, England)

Digging for Something (Superchunk) 2010. From Chapel Hill, North Carolina

Deep South

Song Against Sex (Neutral Milk Hotel) 1996. From Ruston, Louisiana

Slave to the South (The Weeks) 2011. From Florence, Mississippi

Can’t Hold On  (The Black Lips) 2017. From Atlanta, Georgia

Cultural Meccas

Becky (Be Your Own Pet) 2008. From Nashville, Tennessee

Hungry Ghost (Hurray for the Riff Raff) 2017. From New Orleans, Louisiana

Texas and Oklahoma

Do You Realize (The Flaming Lips) 2002. From Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

Actor Out of Work (St. Vincent) 2009.  From Dallas, Texas

Alternative Country

Champaign, Illinois (Old 97's, covering a song written by Bob Dylan and Carl Perkins) 2010. From Dallas, Texas

Thoughts and Prayers (Drive-By Truckers) 2020. From Athens, Georgia

War (Waxahatchee) 2020. From Birmingham, Alabama


Hour 17: The Midwest

Illinois in the 1990s; Alternative Country, Synth-pop, and Emo.

In the 1980s and early 1990s Chicago was the scene where House Music (alternative Dance music) was emerging, and it would go on to strongly influence electronic dance music, trance, and various global forms of dance music. While not as significant to global culture as New York’s contribution of Hip-Hop and rap (rap itself is influenced from the toasting of Jamaican DJs), the people of Chicago can justly be proud of that form of alternative music.  But, alternative and independent music as we are exploring in this series holds closer to rock, punk, folk, synth pop, and country. What was going on in Chicago in the 1990s?  Well, one thing going on was a flourishing of a punk-country or alternative country form, exemplified by WILCO and The Waco Brothers (whose members include several members of the Mekons, a first wave punk band from England that had relocated to Chicago).  

Plenty Tough Union Made (The Waco Brothers) 1995. From Chicago, Illinois (I'll play the 2020 version from the Resist album)

Can’t Stand It (WILCO) 1999. From Chicago, Illinois

Other stuff going on in the late 1990s, included emo music, ("emo" for "emotional").  This was a widespread alternative genre, and I want to share an example from Braid, a band out of Central Illinois, where I have lived for the past couple decades.  But first, the retro-New Wave sound from the Pulsars, two brothers from the Chicago area, singing about their pet robot. Science fiction has been a frequent theme in some alternative music forms. 

My Pet Robot (The Pulsars) 1997. From Chicago, Illinois

Milwaukee Sky Rocket (Braid) 1998. From Champaign-Urbana, Illinois

Indiana and Ohio

Takmit (Saintseneca) 2014. From Columbus, Ohio

Anthropocene (Peter Oren) 2017. From Bloomington, Indiana

Maria (Frances Luke Accord) 2018. From South Bend, Indiana

Trees We Couldn't Tell the Size of (wished bone) 2019. From Athens, Ohio

The National

Carin at the Liquor Store (The National) 2017.  From Cincinnati, Ohio

Turtleneck (The National) 2017. From Cincinnati, Ohio

Northern bands

Holocene (Bon Iver) 2011. From Eau Claire, Wisconsin

You Were Born (Cloud Cult) 2010. From Duluth, Minnesota

Mississippi (The Cactus Blossoms) 2016. From Minneapolis, Minnesota

Concerning The UFO Sighting Near Highland, Illinois (Sufjan Stevens) 2005. From Michigan, but he has lived in New York since the late 1990s)

We will conclude this episode with two more from Chicago.  Andrew Bird is a classically trained musician  with a degree in violin performance, who seems to be involved in almost all forms of music and an unimaginably wide range of instruments. We will hear his 2007 meditation on the course of history and the end of empires, Scythian Empires.  Then, we will hear a song from OK Go, who are now based in Los Angeles, California, but got their start in Chicago, and you may have seen their videos, which are often attention-grabbing.

Scythian Empires (Andrew Bird) 2007. From Chicago, Illinois

This Too Shall Pass (OK Go) 2010. From Chicago, Illinois



Hour 18: The Pacific Northwest

Washington State

 Every Iceburg Is Afire (Sky Cries Mary) 1995.  From Seattle, Washington

No Sunlight (Death Cab For Cutie) 2008.    From Bellingham, Washington

Helplessness Blues (Fleet Foxes) 2011.    From Seattle, Washington

Portland

The Dandy Warhols' T.V. Theme... (The Dandy Warhols) 1995.  From Portland, Oregon

Oakland (Genders) 2013.   From Portland, Oregon (bands with the same name exist in Texas and Israel)

Chinese Translation (M. Ward) 2006.    From Portland, Oregon

Mystic Isle (Jared Mees) 2017.    From Portland, Oregon

Wide Role (Rose City Band) 2019.   From Portland, Oregon

Doug Martsch and Built to Spill

Stay (Doug Martsch) 2002.   From Boise, Idaho

Goin' Against Your Mind (Built To Spill) 2006.    From Boise, Idaho

 Liar (Built To Spill) 2006.    From Boise, Idaho

Aisle 13 (Built To Spill) 2009.    From Boise, Idaho


Hour 19: California and the Southwest

Early stuff

Jane Says (Jane's Addiction) 1987.

Buddy Holly (Weezer) 1994.

Short Skirt/Long Jacket (Cake) 2002.

Intelligent

Letter From Belgium (The Mountain Goats) 2004.

New Roman Times (Camper Van Beethoven) 2004.

My Family's Role In The World Revolution (Beirut) 2007.

Bay Area

Hey World (Remote Control Version) (Michael Franti & Spearhead) 2009.

Bizness (tUnE-yArDs) 2011. From Oakland, California

Palmreader (Sonny & The Sunsets) 2013.  From San Francisco

Southern California

Cloudlight (Eskmo) 2010.  From Los Angeles (but originally from Connecticut)

Sometime Around Midnight (The Airborne Toxic Event) 2009.

Simple Song (The Shins) 2012.

Ends of the Earth (Lord Huron) 2013.


Hour 20: The United Kingdom

The 80s

Song to the Siren (This Mortal Coil) 1984.

Do It Anyway (Woodentops) 1985.

One Great Thing (Big Country) 1986.

You Trip Me Up (The Jesus & Mary Chain) 1985.

Hit the North, Part 1 (The Fall) 1988.

Powder Keg (The Fall) 1996.

The 90s

Brimful Of Asha (Cornershop) 1997.

I Don’t Love Anyone (Belle & Sebastian) 1999.

The 10s

Are Friends Electric? (Gary Numan) 1979 (this version is from 2012).

Fireside (Arctic Monkeys) 2013.

3WW (Alt-J) 2017.

Aside from Growing Old (Cate Le Bon) 2017.

Semicircle Song (The Go! Team) 2018. From Brighton, England (this album featured young musicians from Michigan)

Shady Grove (Yola) 2019.


Hour 21: Europe

Iceland

You've Been Flirting Again (Björk) 1995

Með Blóðnasir (Sigur Rós) 2005

Dirty Paws (Of Monsters and Men) 2012

Sweden

Young Folks (Peter Bjorn and John) 2007

I Was Jesus (Hello Saferide) 2014

Trouble in the Streets (Goat) 2016

Switzerland, Portugal, Belgium

Motherland (Silver Firs) 2013

Dry Dry Land (Tap Tap) 2010

Easy (Absynthe Minded) 2019

France

Pas les saisons (Skydancers Remix) (Mina Tindle) 2015

Les Moissons (Radio Elvis) 2016

La vie facile (Julie Blanche) 2015

Russia

Берег (Shore) (Забавные Игры [Funny Games]) 2019

 Издалека (Izdaleka) (Как Никогда [Kak Nikogda]) 2020



Hour 22: The Folk Revival

Fly Around My Pretty Little Miss (Built To Spill) 2001.

Skinny Love (Bon Iver) 2007.

God? (The Dodos) 2008.

5 Years Time (Noah & The Whale) 2008.

Die (Iron & Wine) 2009.

The Cave (Mumford And Sons) 2009.

Starving Robins (Horse Feathers) 2010.

From Finner (Of Monsters and Men) 2011.

Ho Hey (The Lumineers) 2012.

Lightning Bolt (Jake Bugg) 2012.

Time to Run (Lord Huron) 2012.

You Take Yours, I'll Take Mine (Matthew Mole) 2013.

Over Your Roof (Frances Luke Accord) 2014.

Visions (Saintseneca) 2014.

Noah (Amber Run) 2015.





Sunday, February 07, 2021

A long-time China-watcher's thoughts on American diplomacy in East Asia

 Recently Juan Cole shared on his Informed Comment site an essay by Conn M. Hallinan about Biden’s foreign policy concerning China. The correct thesis of the essay was that the Biden administration’s top goal in diplomacy should be avoiding war with China, but Hallinan made made points that I thought misleading or ill-informed. This is a reaction to that article. 

Hallinan claims that a cold war with China would be impossible to win.  This assertion is highly debatable, but a cold war with China would be very destructive and is highly undesirable, so I see no point in nit-picking this claim, as I’m in agreement the main point that we ought to be trying to avoid a cold war with China. China is fully integrated into the world economy, and could play a positive role in trade and exchanges to help avert a climate catastrophe and promote the sort of economic development that would reduce global poverty, and American diplomacy ought to be structured toward achieving that sort of result.


A human rights festival in Taipei, June 4th of 2019

Hallinan claims that the Trump administration created a toxic atmosphere by targeting the Chinese Community Party (CCP) as the worldwide enemy of the United States. This is a one-sided half-truth.  The Chinese Communist Party bears much of the responsibility for any deterioration in relations with the United States. And, while the CCP is not really a “worldwide enemy” of the USA, under the current leadership of Xi Jinping, China has been behaving as a belligerent adversary, perhaps a step or two below that of an actual “enemy” in several cases. And, yes, the Trump administration used rhetoric that was hostile and toxic, and so that lack of diplomatic acumen was a disastrous part of the Trump Administration’s mishandling of our nation’s relationship with China.


Hallinan claims that Mike Pompeo “essentially called for regime change” in China (he is getting that idea from Chas Freeman), and I would call that accusation unfair.  Hallinan offers readers a link to his source for making this claim, where any reader can see what Pompeo actually said, which was: “We must also engage and empower the Chinese people — a dynamic, freedom-loving people who are completely distinct from the Chinese Communist Party.”  So, while Pompeo was saying our opposition to the current incarnation of the CCP must be tough, he was distinguishing this from our attitude towards the Chinese people, and pointing out that the Chinese people cannot and should not be blamed for whatever horrors the CCP commits. That doesn’t seem like a suggestion that there should be a “fight to the death” with the CCP, but that is how Hallinan (mis)characterizes Pompeo’s actual statement. To be fair to Hallinan, he seems to draw much of his understanding of the situation with China from the opinions of Chas Freeman, who has also accused Pompeo of calling for “regime change” in China. Freeman is one of the most intelligent and well-informed former diplomats who knows and understands China, and his basic premise is that our goal with China must be to make it feel secure and unthreatened, and I agree with that. With our shared premise about the importance of America taking a non-threatening approach to China, it would indeed be disastrous if American diplomats or the president did call for regime change in China, but I am not aware that this was something that the Trump administration ever did, although no doubt that administration was crazy enough to have done so. The leadership in China, however, has became extraordinarily paranoid, and leadership in the Chinese diplomatic corps may well have perceived that the USA wanted and was seeking regime change in China, whether or not that fear had any grounding in fact.


This brings up the question of whether the USA should try to deal with existing ruling powers in nations, or work to change those ruling powers.  Would it be better for the USA if the Chinese Communist Party was suddenly rejected by a coalition of dissatisfied party leaders and People’s Liberation Army generals who ordered some sort of new regime, or is it more desirable for the USA if the CCP evolves into a more benevolent party that respects human rights and ceases to threaten murderous violence against the citizens and regimes of American client states and protectorates in Asia? The CCP has done a fairly effective job of brainwashing the Chinese population into a state where many Chinese hold an ugly nationalism with a sort of Han ethnicity chauvinism and militaristic jingoism that would be extremely dangerous if China suddenly became a democracy.  I also know enough about Chinese history to fear any sort of political or military chaos in China such as it experienced in the 1920s to 1949, or at the end of the Ming Dynasty, or the ends of the other dynasties. I am in favor helping the CCP evolve to a point where it respects human rights and is committed to the United Nations’ ideals of peace, and I see no plausible and desirable alternative to that. 


The CCP is a vast organization with millions of members, and I know that it has in its ranks many idealistic and caring people who enthusiastically want to improve their country and maintain friendly relations with all peoples (I have several dear friends who are active members of the Chinese Communist Party), and no doubt there are many nationalistic Chinese in the CCP who stupidly fantasize of world domination and winning a victory in a war with the USA. America has its counterparts to these types.  The Chinese CCP has done some very horrible things in the past few decades (cultural genocide against ethnic minorities in Xinjiang and Tibet, violating international law in the Spratley Islands, threatening war with Taiwan, initiating wars of border expansion against Vietnam and India, supporting the attempt of North Korea to conquer South Korea and consistently lying to the Chinese people about the nature of the Korean conflict, murderous crack-downs on non-violent protesters, violating its treaty promises to the UK in Hong Kong, etc.) and done a few good things as well (successfully reduced poverty, built a massive infrastructure to improve the lives of common Chinese citizens, etc.).  I don’t see value in arguing over how the CCP’s bad behavior compares to American atrocities, except to note that both sides have plenty to be ashamed of (among American atrocities: bombing neutral Cambodia during the war with North Vietnam, “strategic bombing”—otherwise known as the indiscriminate killing of civilians—in North Vietnam, invading and occupying Iraq, sponsoring murderous terrorists fighting legitimate governments, sponsoring violent and bloody overthrowing of democratically elected governments, supporting brutal governments that treated their citizenry in ways that were worse than what China has done internally since the 1980s, etc.). The USA and China both have plenty of blood on their hands, and the Democrats and Republicans of our country have done much evil, which can be compared to the evil done by the CCP.  The Chinese government may freely criticize America’s misbehavior, and I welcome their criticism, because the fact that an actor is imperfect has no logical bearing on the merit of  their arguments against the errors of others. The American government likewise may criticize China’s flaws, and should do so, provided such criticisms don’t make matters worse.


The problem is, under Xi Jinping, the CCP has been doing a lot more misbehaving, and so the tone of criticism has naturally been getting stronger. The rift between the governments in Washington and Beijing should not be entirely blamed on the general stupidity and incompetence of President Trump’s diplomacy. China’s behavior would have caused some degree of distancing between the two governments even under a competent and wise administration in Washington.


Hallinan points out that people in China and the United States have lower opinions of each other’s countries.  He links to an article showing that in America only 26% have a favorable view of China, whereas 66% view it negatively. Is such a massive shift in public opinion plausibly the result of Trump’s racist and antagonistic anti-Chinese rhetoric, or might actual behaviors of the Chinese government or Chinese people had something to do with it? Look at the poll Hallinan’s source referred to, and you find that the things that Americans identify as the three most significant problems for the U.S. in its relationship with China are: 1) China’s impact on the global environment; 2) Cyberattacks from China; and 3) China’s policies on human rights.  I don’t recall any of these three things being emphasized by Trump.  Trump’s main concerns seemed to be the USA's trade deficits with China or loss of U.S. jobs to China, and those are identified as “problems” by 5 percentage points to 12 percentage points fewer Americans than the three top problems I’ve mentioned. Also, the growth in strong negative feelings against China are a global phenomena, not merely an American phenomenon.  Polling by the same Pew Charitable Trust that gave us the evidence that Americans distrust China and see its government as a problem tell us that unfavorable views of China are held by 81% of Australians, 86% of Japanese, 73% of Spaniards, 75% of South Koreans, 85% of French, 73% of Canadians, and so forth.  Since only 66% of Americans have an unfavorable view of China, it hardly makes sense to argue that Trump had much to do with making Americans more distrustful or hostile towards China. On the contrary, Americans seem less hostile toward China compared with the views of citizens in other developed countries. 


And what of the views of Chinese towards America?  In China, the CCP controls the media narrative, and aside form a small minority of technically-savvy Chinese who can use VPN to look at media outside the CCP’s firewall isolating Chinese people from free exchange of facts and opinion on the internet, most people in China only know what the CCP lets them know.  So, if Chinese opinion toward foreigners and foreign nations is getting more hostile, and the Chinese sense of self is becoming more nationalistic or belligerently chauvinistic, that probably has something to do with the way the CCP is presenting the world to the population they rule.  


Hallinan offers a paragraph that is quite accurate and good, and provides readers with the best point in his essay:


Most Chinese think the U.S. is determined to isolate their country, surround it with hostile allies, and prevent it from becoming a world power. Many Americans think China is an authoritarian bully that has robbed them of well-paying industrial jobs. There is a certain amount of truth in both viewpoints. The trick will be how to negotiate a way through some genuine differences.


Yes, there are genuine differences, and negotiating through those differences is what we must do. The emphasis here is on negotiating as opposed to bullying or threatening as those approaches, with their reliance on American military force, are not good options.


Hallinan has an academic background in anthropology, rather than history, so his historical statements are not always perfectly true.  The century from 1839 to 1939 is (rightly, I think) presented as China’s century of humiliation, when it was mistreated by foreign powers, but Hallinan describes America as one of the colonial powers (like the UK, France, Japan, and Germany) that fought wars and seized ports from China in those years. The USA did engage in the extortionate punitive treatment of the Qing government after the Qing had supported anti-foreigner atrocities committed by the Boxers. Mark Twain wrote a brilliant satirical essay about this, “To the Person Sitting in Darkness,” which is my favorite anti-imperialism essay. But in general, the USA had a different sort of relationship with China compared to those other powers, and asked China to give the USA the same trading advantages it gave to any other foreign power. The USA did not attack China or seize ports as the other imperial powers did.  The relationship was also colored by the fact that many Chinese lived in the United States, and there was a long and close relationship between some American merchant capitalists from New England and some Chinese tycoons of Guangzhou. America really did have a “special” relationship with China that was significantly different from the relations of the other imperialist powers. The CCP may have tried to erase this fact from the way it tells historical narratives to its populace, and Hallinan may only care about what Chinese believe about history, rather than historical facts, since it is perceptions of history rather than actual history that is most likely to condition how people and governments behave. 


Hallinan asserts that “the Chinese have never forgotten those dark years” and I think he is only right in the literal sense the those years weren’t erased from history books.  The Chinese intellectual classes of the 1920s and 1930s had a variety of opinions about the diplomacy and conflict between the Qing Court and the Western Powers and Japan. The Nationalist Party that occupied and brutalized the people of Taiwan certainly downplayed the century of humiliation, and the CCP used to present a historical narrative about the century of humiliation that fit that era into a standard Marxist history about capitalist powers seeking to expand markets and grab resources, placing China’s position as one similar to that of Africa, India, or Latin America.  It has only been in the past two or three decades that the historical narratives about the century of humiliation have been associated with a strong nationalist sense of resentment and hostility toward the USA and European powers. That is to say, the Chinese were always angry about foreign powers pushing them around, and the weakness and inability of the Qing and Republican governments to successfully face the bullying and aggression of Japanese and European powers made many Chinese extremely xenophobic. However, until this century, the rhetoric of the Chinese Marxists who complained about foreign dominance in China used to fit into a framework that did not suggest that the Chinese people were particularly aggrieved or disadvantaged compared to other peoples of less developed nations. International worker solidarity and class consciousness was favored, and explanatory models fit into a Marxist universalism that (correctly) blamed capitalist classes in foreign lands and their allied elites in China for exploiting poor people and eroding local sovereignty as part of a universal political and economic unfolding of history. In this century, the Chinese-generated narratives have changed toward a more nationalistic and ethnocentric story emphasizing the exploitation of China and the victimization of the Chinese.  I know a bit about this because I audited a course in Chinese historiography as a doctoral student in the mid-1990s, and I’ve followed with interest the way Chinese and Taiwanese historians present their history to their publics ever since. The emphasis on China’s humiliation and the need to rise and be strong to prevent any further insults to the Chinese sense of pride and worth is a fairly new thing.  It was certainly not a central narrative in Chinese history in the 1970s or 1980s, but it does seem to be a major emphasis of China’s sense of its world situation in the past decade or two.  That is a regrettable and dangerous change. 



Hallinan claims that the Chinese have never threatened to interdict trade in the South China Sea. This is a debatable point. In 2020 the Chinese coast guard and navy have attacked and killed Vietnamese fishermen near the Parcel Islands, and in 2019 the Chinese sank a Philippines’ boat off Reed Bank and left 22 Fishermen floating in the ocean until they were picked up by a Vietnamese boat. Sinking and killing fishermen in international waters seems more serious than merely “threatening” to interdict trade.  And, of course, the authorities in Beijing have threatened to interdict trade with Taiwan, which lies at the northern boundary of the South China Sea.  When Hallinan then characterizes the Chinese authorities as being essentially non-belligerent and peaceful by pretending that they have never threatened to interdict trade in the South China Sea, he is doing so to set up Chinese behavior in contrast to American behavior, and he mentions the Malabar war games and the American strategy of “Air Sea Battle” since those do aim to prepare for cutting off Chinese trade through the South Chinese Sea. But he fails to consider under what circumstances the United States would try to cut off Chinese trade.  The only plausible circumstances in which the USA would do that would be if China were involved in aggressive wars against Korea, Japan, or Taiwan, the three American protectorates or client states in East Asia. If China would renounce the use of force or stop claiming it had a right to invade and conquer Taiwan, and if it would stop supporting the belligerent regime in North Korea, America and other powers in Asia could stop preparing to cut off China’s sea trade.  Any comment on the allegedly hostile American preparation to contain China should, in fairness, mention what China does in its military war games and diplomatic rhetoric to prepare for an attack on Taiwan, Japan, and South Korea.


Hallinan is right that the West needs to be sensitive to China’s insecurities.  The main point he is making is correct as far as that goes. Yet, his presentation is ignoring China’s actual violent belligerence in the South China Sea, and its threats to use violence against its East Asian neighbors, and that is an error.


I think Hallinan is largely informed by the opinions of Chas Freeman, who was one of three American translators during Nixon’s famous 1972 visit to China.  Freeman is a brilliant diplomat, well-connected in China and Taiwan, who expresses many opinions about America’s foreign policy, and I agree with the vast majority of what he says.  Chas Freeman is very good at expressing the Chinese view of the situation related to Taiwan (his December 17, 2020 talk “War with China over Taiwan” will give you an idea of how Freeman sees the situation). Usually when Freeman expresses opinions I disagree with, I perceive he has become so empathetically understanding of the CCP’s view (which is a good trait in a diplomat) that he has taken the Chinese view as his own (which is the source of my disagreement with him, I think).  As Hallinan and Freeman see the situation, the U.S. has abrogated agreements our diplomats and leaders made with China in 1972, 1978, 1979, and 1982.  China also made some assurances in those agreements, and Hallinan and Freeman emphasize how American foreign policy has violated the spirit of those agreements without saying much about how the Chinese have violated those agreements. I assume Freeman doesn’t examine those because he is interested in realpolitik and considers the only important issue is how China perceives the situation, rather than what the situation actually is or was. For example, China believes that there has been a consensus among China, the USA, and Taiwan that there is only one China and there cannot be a two states for one country solution to the problem of the “division” of China. When the KMT ruled Taiwan as a dictatorship and an occupying Chinese regime bullying the local Taiwanese population, the KMT did agree with China on that view, and it was at that time (the 1960s and 1970s) that Chas Freeman came to understand Taiwan and China, and make his friendships with elites and leadership in both countries. The KMT is no longer in power in Taiwan, and when they are in power they do not rule in a dictatorship, and so the government in Taiwan has changed, and no longer represents a Chinese government-in-exile that seeks reunification with the Chinese motherland. 


Hallinan suggests that both countries should dial down the rhetoric and de-escalate their military deployments.  That is actually good advice. He also suggests that Beijing should give up its claims in the South China Sea and disarm the bases it has illegally established there.  That is also good advice, although there are other solutions that would not require this (for example, setting up the Spratleys and Parcel Islands in a situation like that of Andorra where multiple countries hold a form of joint-sovereignty over a region, or share mutual responsibilities for protecting a common resource).  He should also suggest that China re-affirm its agreements made in 1979 and 1982 that it will not seek to reunify with Taiwan through violent force.  China has broken its treaty with the UK about the treatment of institutions and the population in Hong Kong. China’s threat to violently attack and murder thousands of Taiwanese for the frivolous sake of national pride and unity, to conquer Taiwan, also conflicts with the understandings reached with the United States in 1979 and 1982.


One thing that might help the situation with Taiwan and China is for the Taiwanese government to make several suggestions for how reunification could be achieved on Taiwan’s terms.  These could be creative solutions, and there ought to be several suggestions.  One approach would be to suggest forms of reunion in which the two states became allies and partners in a system of equal power-sharing, where any changes in the relationship could be vetoed by either side. There could also be clauses in the reunification treaty that would allow either side to become independent from the other if there was a violation of some agreement.  For example, each side might keep its own military, and if either side used its military in the other’s territory for purposes other than humanitarian relief or coordinated mutual defense, that would trigger the dissolution of the unified state. Some sort of a confederation solution might be found that finds a middle-ground between the unification of the American states into the USA (too much unification for Taiwan) and the confederation of the members of the European Union (not enough unification for China).  Taiwan needs to make these sorts of suggestions and engage with China in discussions about the sort of reunification that would appeal to the Taiwanese (reunifications in which there would be no possibility of the CCP or PLA eroding the rights or democratic institutions in Taiwan as they have done in Hong Kong) in order to take from the CCP any sort of excuse for launching the terrible efforts of a violent conquest of Taiwan. A treaty of confederation between Taiwan and the PRC might begin with an idealistic preamble pointing out the advantages of nations and peoples binding their countries together close enough to make violent conflict unthinkable, but allowing local sovereignty and self-determination so that large nations cannot interfere in smaller nations, extolling the virtue of diverse approaches to the basic problems of governance and securing stability, justice, and flourishing civilizations.   Humanity needs to try out many different policies and approaches and seek out methods that seem most desirable for creating flourishing and stable societies, but humanity also needs governments to surrender a certain amount of sovereignty in order to prevent inter-state warfare. A treating binding Taiwan and China together could offer the confederation as a model  for potential unification of Asia, and then eventually unification of the planet. References could be made to the successes of the European Union, NATO, and various long-standing mutual defense alliances and peaceful neighborly relations among nations. If Taiwan is continuously suggesting such agreements, and China is always rejecting them, this would create a better situation than one in which Taiwan seems to only want to follow a path toward independence without any dialog with China.


The dream of Taiwan simply being a normal independent country like Japan or South Korea is not plausible because the CCP will not accept that, and neither Taiwan nor the USA can afford a war with China.  The CCP’s dream of conquering Taiwan or taking over Taiwan the way it took over Hong Kong is equally impossible, because the people of Taiwan do not want it and would violently resist, and the United States cannot afford to have a client state or protectorate forcibly conquered by China.  There are other solutions between those two unacceptable extremes. We do not need to wait for China to give up its claims to have a right to conquer Taiwan (the Chinese use the euphemism “reunification”), or persuade it to do so. Exploring other solutions that could be acceptable to Taiwanese, and offering such solutions to the CCP on a regular basis, would at least get the leadership of the CCP to ponder some sort of reunification that would give the Beijing government the minimum it desires (the ability to claim it has successfully reunified China and greater security of its territorial integrity) while not actually giving it any significant power to dominate or interfere in Taiwanese sovereignty. The Chinese are naturally pragmatic, and if discussion and diplomacy begins in earnest toward some sort of agreement for a confederation, the Taiwanese and Americans might have a chance of waiting out the current belligerent Xi Jinping regime and getting a more pragmatic and conciliatory successor regime after Xi to negotiate in good faith and accept some accommodation with Taiwan. 


Protestors outside the Executive Assembly during Taipei’s Sunflower Protest Movement, 2014

While China continues to be belligerent and violent in its pursuit of territorial expansion in the South China Sea and dominance of Asia, it is necessary for the United States to cooperate with other Asian powers to constrain and blunt this aggression, but American diplomacy cannot merely take a role as China’s opposition or enemy in Asia. On the contrary, American diplomacy requires a break-through in which China can see its self-interest furthered through a friendly partnership with its Asian neighbors and the United States, and this requires America and its friends in Asia to offer China various alternatives to the present highly confrontational situation in East Asia, and especially across the Formosan Straits.  


Another approach to China would be some sort of an entente or mutual defense alliance among the major Asian players aside from China. The USA would need to put together this agreement among Japan, Taiwan, the USA, Singapore, Malaysia, the Philippines, Vietnam, Australia, New Zealand, Thailand, Indonesia, and India, with all agreeing that China has disputes with some of these nations (Vietnam, Indonesia, Taiwan, and Philippines) about sovereignty in the Spratley and Parcel Islands, about borders (with India and Vietnam, and Japan), and about sovereignty (with Taiwan). The nations would commit to an intention to see all these disputes with China resolved peacefully in ways that are acceptable to China and to all the partners.  The partners would agree that violent military confrontation by China to force its way in any of these disputes would be unacceptable, and would be met by a unified defensive action. It would not be good to only agree to defend against Chinese aggression; it would be necessary for the entente agreement to recognize that these disputes create insecurity, and everyone wants to see these disputes resolved, and the only plausible resolution of these disputes is to see solutions in which both China and its neighbors peacefully find compromise and agreement.


Whatever happens in Asian international relations, two principles ought to be recognized by the United States and incorporated into its diplomatic posture.  The first of these is that American values recognize the philosophical principle that all lives are of equal value, and given the equal value of human lives, the largest Asian nations of China and India, and to a lesser extent Indonesia, have something like a “natural” right to take a leadership role in the international order in Asia. This needs to be acknowledged to assure China that the USA accepts its role as a natural leader in Asia (but not “the” natural leader).  The United States would thus recognize that China has a certain degree of responsibility and some degree of an inherent right to sometimes lead the diplomatic fashioning of a peaceful order in Asia. The corollary principle that must accompany this stance based on the equal value of human life is the principle that each nation has a right to independent sovereignty and freedom from unwanted interference from larger states.  Thus, states with smaller populations, such as Mongolia, Timor-Leste, and Bhutan have a right to security where they are free from aggression and dominance by their larger neighbors, and whatever order of international relations emerges must protect the independence and sovereignty of smaller states. The United States also ought to emphasize that the principles of the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Sustainable Development Goals that emerged from the United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development in Rio de Janeiro in 2012,  the goals of the COP21 Paris Climate Conference and the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction express the shared goals of all governments, and central to all these agreements are the  principles that governments have a duty to improve the lives of people and protect humanity from the horrors of war. And, thus, all states should join to secure peace and stop any power from using warfare as a tool to settle disputes. This can be emphasized as a way of demonstrating that the same principles that guide American diplomacy to prevent the CCP from using military conquest to subjugate the peoples of Taiwan or take control over islands in the South China sea that actually belong to Vietnam, Indonesia, and the Philippines also guide American diplomacy to honor China’s right to leadership and power in international relations.


What do I know about Asia? I have visited and briefly lived in China four times. I visited friends there in the summer of 1992 for not quite two weeks, studied Chinese in Xi’an in the summer of 1994 for about seven weeks, visited Shanghai for the World Fair for a bit less than two weeks in 2010, and was a short-term exchange scholar at Heilongjiang University in Harbin for nearly two months in the late spring of 2012.  I have also lived in Taiwan or visited it for extended periods off an on since 1990, accumulating about four years of my life living in Taiwan. I have many friendships with Chinese from a variety of walks of life, and I remain in contact with about a dozen Chinese citizens, all of whom I dearly cherish as friends. I have been married to a woman from Taiwan for nearly 30 years, and count Taiwanese citizens among my closest and most intimate friends.  I have had a scholarly interest in China since the early 1980s in my adolescence, and over the past 40 years I have read scores of scholarly and popular books and articles on many aspects of Chinese history and society.  I’m not a China expert, but I’m fairly well-informed about China, and very well informed about Taiwan. My Chinese language skills are intermediate, and I’m working on building them up toward fluency.